Opinions
Opinion: Visit to 68th District Court
- Details
- By Kate Cole
- Saturday, October 01, 2011
- Hits: 635
Last week, I watched justice unfold in Judge Tracey Collier-Nix's 68th District courtroom.
What became apparent was that justice was being served at the expense of every taxpayer in the city for three young men accused of having stolen property and a shotgun in their possession when arrested.
Each of the three men had a court appointed attorney plus an attorney who was overseeing them.
Besides four court-appointed attorneys, there were two court clerks (one electronically taping the proceedings) the judge and two courtroom police officers. There also was the prosecuting attorney and a police sergeant who brought in the evidence identified as being stolen from two victims who had testified before.
I don't usually think dollars and sense in a courtroom setting. But if I were to tabulate what it cost to bring the suspects to this preliminary hearing, I would guess the tab would be substantial — thousands of dollars.
This proceeding was called an arraignment. Was there enough evidence to put the three on trial was to be determined.
I was surprised at the way the defense trio cross-examined the Flint policewoman who gave testimony on how she and her partner risked their lives to capture the armed men.
As I listened to the testimony, I wondered why a young policewoman would risk her life. Why she was dragged by defense attorneys through muddy innuendos of giving misleading evidence. Why every consideration was given to the suspects — but not to the victims or police.
I admired the judge who saw through this masquerading of justice and allowed witnesses to tell their own stories. She is the sole authority to determine if the case will go to circuit court where the defendants could request a jury.
I believe our scales of justice are tipping towards perpetrators who, if found guilty, will not pay back a fraction of the cost it will take to rightly convict and house them for the length of their prison term.
Did these three young men get a fair hearing? I thought they did. Are they guilty? Only a jury or judge in circuit court can decide.
But wait. The cost in dollars and cents isn't the most important issue we're facing as a city or as a nation. How did these three young men get to where they are today?
Let's suppose these young men are proven guilty. We've lost three potential productive citizens — perhaps future scientists, doctors, lawyers or judges. When released from prison they will face almost insurmountable challenges. Who will give a felon a job? Their chances of offending again are high.
Unless we, as members of the greatest democracy in the world, have the courage to make some changes in our country at all levels, including education, how we handle absentee parents, pay-to-stay prison reform and a host of other personal changes that say we want every individual to be part of our society, whatever the cost, the cycle will continue.
Shouldn't the number of nationally incarcerated, 1.5 million in 2008, shock us? In 2007 Michigan had over 51,000 in their prisons. Is this people-drain enough to cause us to pause and think about why people turn to crime in the most favorable opportunistic country in the world?
By chance, I met another 68th District Court judge, Herman Marable, the following day. He was advocating his student of the month and year program aimed at 10th graders.
Students submit essays about their career goals. Winners are awarded a savings bond by the judge and chance to shadow him for a day. Press releases honor the student's efforts.
And, hopefully, students get a glimpse of a better life in a democracy that rewards its citizens with good government.
- Visitors
- 4
- Articles
- 2720
- Articles View Hits
- 1635493
Fast Links
Notices
Average hits a day on stories in last 30 days: 2,491.
Average hits a day on web site in last 30 days: 622.
Hits on stories Jan. 15, 2010 to April 12, 2013: 4,512,519.
Hits on web site Jan. 15, 2010 to April 12, 2013: 257,727.
Hits on stories April 13 to May 12: 51,535.
Hits on web site April 13 to May 12: 17,178
Hits on stories March 13 to April 12: 60,182.
Hits on web site March 13 to April 12: 19,082.
Hits on stories Feb. 13 to March 12: 67,293.
Hits on web site Feb. 13 to March 12: 14,788.
Hits on stories Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 54,538.
Hits on web site Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 18,198
Hits on stories Dec. 13 to Jan. 12: 71,290.
Hits on web site Dec. 13 to Jan. 12: 15,870.
Hits on stories Nov. 13 to Dec. 12: 113,197
Hits on web site Nov. 13 to Dec.. 12: 16,849
_______________________________________________
Hits on stories Oct. 13 to Nov. 12: 132,525
Hits on web site Oct. 13 to Nov. 12: 16,570.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hits on stories Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 113,654
Hits on web site Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 15,448
Hits on stories Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 91,003
Hits on web site Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 9,869
Hits on stories July 13 to Aug.12: 59,238
Hits on web site July 13 to Aug. 12: 6,804
Hits on stories June 13 to July 12: 48,151
Hits on web site June 13 to July 12: 6,589
Hits on stories May 13 to June 12: 45,956
Hits on web site May 13 to June 12: 7,209
Hits on stories April 13 to May 12: 38,676
Hits on web site April 13 to May 12: 3,857
Hits on stories March 13 to April 12: 45,240
Hits on web site March 13 to April 12: 3,907
Hits on stories Feb. 13 to March 12: 25,114
Hits on web site Feb. 13 to March 12: 4,081
Hits on stories Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 12,400
Hits on web site Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 6,491
Hits on stories Dec. 13 to Jan. 12: 12,400
Hits on web site Dec. 13 to now: 6,524
Hits on stories Nov. 13 to Dec. 12: 12,800
Hits on web site Nov. 13 to Dec. 12: 7,044
Hits on stories Oct. 13 to Nov. 12: 12,000
Hits on web site Oct. 13 to Nov. 12: 6,524
Hits on stories Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 12,000
Hits on web site Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 6,359
Hits on stories Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 12,800
Hits on web site Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 6,107
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories July 13 to Aug. 12: 17,800
Hits on web site to July 13 to Aug. 12: 6,407
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories June 13 to July 12: 20,400
Hits on web site June 13 to July 12: 6,784
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories May 13 to June 12: 22,800
Hits on web site May 13 to June 12: 6,229
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories April 13 to May 12: 18,800
Hits on web site April 13 to May 12: 3,469
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories March 13 to April 12: 21,220
Hits on web site March 13 to April 12: 3,699
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Feb. 13 to March 12: 25,420
Hits on web site Feb. 13 to March 12: 3,005
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 24,636
Hits on web site Jan. 13 to Feb. 12: 3,508
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Dec. 13 to Jan. 12: 22,600
Hits on web site Dec. 13 to Jan 12: 2,937
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Nov. 13 to Dec. 12: 17,280
Hits on web site Nov. 13 to Dec. 12: 2,372
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Oct. 13 to Nov. 12: 9,752
Hits on web site Oct. 13 to Nov. 13: 2,596
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 16,700
Hits on web site Sept. 13 to Oct. 12: 1,898
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 14,572
Hits on web site Aug. 13 to Sept. 12: 1,760
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories July 13 to Aug. 12: 6,072
Hits on web site July 13 to Aug. 12: 1,442
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories June 13 to July 12: 2,905
Hits on web site June 13 to July 12: 1,205
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories May 13 to June 12: 4,005
Hits on web site May 13 to June 12: 1,481
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories April 13 to May 12: 3,003
Hits on web site April 13 to May 12: 1,467
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories March 13 to April 12: 2,229
Hits on web site March 13 to April 12: 1,538
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Feb. 13 to March 12: 1,991
Hits on the web site Feb. 13 to March 12: 1,485
–––––––––––––––––––––––––
Hits on stories Jan. 15 to Feb. 12: 2,378
Hits on web site Jan. 15 to Feb. 12: 1,839
Hits on stories Nov.13 to Dec. 12: 113,197
Hits on web site Nov. 13 to Dec.. 12: 16,849
